Comparison Between Canon 5D mark II and Nikon D700
September 18, 2008
Canon 5D Mark II vs Nikon D700
Canon has done it again, undoubtedly, they are the leader in technological innovations for DSLRs but have they gone too far? is HD Movie really needed or wanted on a DIGITAL CAMERA? for now It is safe to say that photographer prefer their CAMERAs to take still shots… if they wanted to take HD Movies, it may be a wiser idea to get a HD VIDEO camera that has all the features for a good HD Video Camera instead of cramming a good SLR with a so-so HD VIDEO Recorder, but i may be wrong…
Now back to the comparison of the 2 cameras. Canon definitely has outdone Nikon in the Megapixel category but it remains to be seen if the picture quality is much better.. Why do I say this? When I talked about pixel Density earlier (D700 vs D300) Technically, the D700 (36×24) supposedly had cleaner files since pixel density was less than than that of the D300 (23.6×15.8).. it was D700 at 1.4MP/cm2 vs the D300 at 3.3MP/cm2.
In this comparison both D700 and Canon 5D Mark II both have the same sensor size at 36×24.. The difference will be on pixel density.. since the Canon 5D sports a 21mp resolution, it packs more pixels per cm2 at 2.4MP/cm2 while the D700 at 12.1MP packs around 1.4MP/cm2. Technically, the D700 should have cleaner files but the differences may only be evident once you print large sized images.
At this resolution, the lens quality shall play a big part in the image capture. Bad Glass will standout and defects like barrel distortion, pincushion distortion will be more obvious. Like the D700, vignetting will be a problem on some of canon’s lenses. Packed with good lenses, more detail and info can be captured on the 5D.. fine details and more definition than the 12.1MP D700.
The Canon 5D has 8 positions for the white balance while the D700 has only 6, Not a critical feature if you ask me, since the D700 white balance settings can be controlled on the Kelvin Scale.
The D700 has a built in flash, but is it really used? it can come in handy at times and might be a plus if extra light is really needed.
If extra exposure is needed the edge goes to the D700 having -5 to +5 with 1/3 EV or set it to 1/2EV.. this is a plus since the Canon only goes up to -2 to +2 with 1/3EV or 1/2EV.
Speed goes to Nikon D700 with 5 FPS per second and 8FPS with attached battery pack while the Canon 5D mark II is just a tiny bit faster at 3.5FPS than the 1st generation counterpart Canon 5D.
In Terms of Viewing the images, the Canon 5D gives a better feel since you can see 98% of the image that is captured and not limited by the 95% coverage of th D700.. (a quirk anyone can live with)
Its packs more megapixel does that mean it should weight more? nope not neccessarily true, the Canon 5D packs 21.0MP and only weights 850g while the Nikon D700 is on the heavy side at 1074g. This may be a deal breaker for some since they like to lug around lighter gear and with more women coming into the photography scene, maybe canon is givng them a power packed option in a lighter packaging? maybe..
Ok now comes the part where we talk about the canon HD Movie recorder again.. is the 1080p video recorder really needed by the photographer? It may come in handy for wedding photogrphers or your typical family photographer. Did they release the Movie feature with a high end camera to get the professionals to sell the idea to the basic consumers? maybe.. to justify eventually adding this as a standard feature for future upgrades of the lower end models, giving the consumer another reason to spend! will it catch on? this remains to be seen.
Which is a better camera? again it depends on your use.. but the 21MP will come in handy for big prints.. ok maybe billboard prints.. with 21MP watch your hardisk space VANISH.. then the cycle of having to upgrade computers and hardisk space and all that will happen again.. it is a vicious cycle..
Canon 5D Mark II with HD Movie Recording and 21.1 MP
September 18, 2008
Ok.. here we go again, Canon setting the pace in Digital Camera Technology.. introducing HD Movie recording Feature.. Will it spur the market to buy and upgrade? am not too sure now that the world is in a financial crunch and people are tightening their belts.
Expect Nikon to come up with their answer soon.. but is having an HD Movie feature on cam a feature that is really needed by the photographer? a tool is better off specializing than being an all in one solution. example, a video camera will always perform better as a hd video camera because of its basic make up and that it was designed solely for that purpose.. rather than a DSLR wanting to be a video camera.
I could be wrong.. what do you guys think?
| CANON U.S.A. INTRODUCES THE HIGHLY ANTICIPATED EOS 5D MARK II DSLR CAMERA FEATURING FULL-FRAME HD VIDEO CAPTURE |
| The Canon EOS 5D Mark II Escalates Full-Frame Digital SLR Photography to the Next Level with HD Movie Recording Capabilities, DIGIC 4 Imaging Processor, and 21.1 Megapixel Resolution |
| LAKE SUCCESS, N.Y., September 17, 2008 – Canon U.S.A., Inc., a leader in digital imaging, today introduced the EOS 5D Mark II Digital SLR camera, the long-awaited successor to Canon’s highly popular EOS 5D, introduced in 2005. Building upon the qualities that made the EOS 5D camera so successful, Canon has coupled the creative power of a full-frame CMOS sensor in a relatively compact and affordable camera body, together with groundbreaking HD video capture that opens the door to a much wider range of imaging possibilities for photographers. Along with the ability to capture full HD video clips at 1920 x 1080 resolution, Canon’s EOS 5D Mark II Digital SLR camera features a 21.1-megapixel full frame 24 x 36mm CMOS sensor, DIGIC 4 imaging processor and significantly lower noise, with an expanded sensitivity range from ISO 50 to ISO 25,600. The anticipation surrounding the launch of this camera model has exceeded our greatest expectations, and we believe our loyal customers will be awed by the level of innovation and features built into the new EOS 5D Mark II Digital SLR. Once they have the chance to experience the camera, we believe they will agree that it was worth the wait,” stated Yuichi Ishizuka, senior vice president and general manager, Consumer Imaging Group, Canon U.S.A. Among the many advancements in Canon’s new EOS 5D Mark II camera is the Company’s proprietary DIGIC 4 Imaging Processor that powers the camera’s fast 14-bit analog-to-digital conversion for smooth color tones and exceptional gradation. The Canon EOS 5D Mark II Digital SLR offers a full-frame 24 x 36mm, 21.1 megapixel CMOS sensor and continuous shooting at 3.9 frames per second (fps) for an unlimited number of full-resolution JPEGs to the capacity of the memory card or up to 14 RAW images in a single burst when using a UDMA CF card. The camera includes a 15-point Autofocus (AF) sensor with nine selectable AF points plus six additional Assist AF points (three center AF points sensitive to f/2.8 lenses) with enhanced light source detection and AF microadjustment for greater autofocus performance. The EOS 5D Mark II camera also features a large, clear 3.0-inch Clear View LCD screen with 920,000 dot/VGA resolution, four times the pixel count of the EOS 5D camera’s 2.5-inch screen, for enhanced clarity and color when viewing images. The new camera is equipped with a high-performance, high-magnification optical viewfinder providing 98 percent coverage, giving a new dimension to the saying, “what you see is what you get.” Professional photographers will also appreciate the enhanced 150,000-cycle shutter durability of the EOS 5D Mark II camera. Canon, the first company to introduce a full-frame digital camera, has improved the EOS 5D Mark II Digital SLR camera’s newly developed full-frame CMOS image sensor. Utilizing proprietary Canon technology, the Company has reduced noise and expanded the sensitivity of the CMOS sensor up to ISO 25600, which is three full stops higher than the ISO 3200 limit of the original EOS 5D camera. Although the individual pixel dimensions of the EOS 5D Mark II camera are the same as the 21.1-megapixel CMOS sensor used in the EOS-1Ds Mark III digital SLR, the new sensor incorporates an improved output amplifier and a more advanced color filter that improves light transmission while retaining excellent color reproduction. By applying the same kind of advancements in sensor design and image processing technology as the recently introduced EOS 50D camera, but at higher resolution and with larger pixels, the EOS 5D Mark II achieves the highest level of image quality of any EOS Digital SLR released to date. With the combination of its improved CMOS image sensor and the powerful new DIGIC 4 image processor, the Canon EOS 5D Mark II camera provides ISO speeds from ISO 100 up to ISO 6400 in 1/3-stop increments, along with two high-speed settings - H1 and H2 - of ISO 12800 and ISO 25600, respectively, as well as a low-speed setting of ISO 50. The full-frame sensor maximizes the performance of Canon EF lenses, the world’s largest selection of autofocus lenses. HD and SD Video Capture The EOS 5D Mark II will record video up to 4GB per clip or a maximum continuous movie capture time of 29 minutes and 59 seconds, whichever comes first. Depending on the level of detail in the scene, a 4GB memory card can record approximately 12 minutes of video at full HD resolution or approximately 24 minutes in standard definition.i Video clips are recorded in .MOV format using an MPEG-4 video compression and sound is recorded using linear PCMii without compression. The new camera features an input terminal for external stereo microphones as well as a built-in monaural microphone for convenience. To help show off those fantastic movies as well as still photos, the EOS 5D Mark II camera includes an HDMI (High-Definition Multimedia Interface) output to display crisp, clear images on a High-Definition TV. Live View Shooting Live mode uses contrast-detection AF with the image sensor and here, as with Quick mode, users can change the AF point using the Multi-controller. Face Detection Live mode uses contrast AF to recognize human faces. When multiple faces are detected, the largest face closest to the center of the frame is targeted as the AF point. While Live View is engaged users can still change settings including the AF mode (Quick, Live, Face Detection Live mode), drive mode, ISO speed, Picture style, White Balance, and more. Peripheral Illumination Correction Auto Lighting Optimizer Canon’s New Creative Auto Mode Two Small RAW Formats Silent Shooting in Live View EOS Integrated Cleaning System Pricing and Availability New EF 24mm f/1.4L II USM Lens About Canon U.S.A., Inc. All referenced product names, and other marks, are trademarks of their respective owners. i According to Canon’s standard test methods. |








